By Zachary Karabell
In the cold dark of a premarket December morning in 1930 , four clerks emerged from the service entrance of the office building at 39 Broadway , each with a cart loaded with documents . They hauled those carts for only a few blocks , to the newly refurbished and expanded offices at 59 Wall Street , the marbled site of one of the most storied firms on Wall Street , Brown Brothers . The carts contained stock and bond certificates that the Harriman family , whose fortune had been born in the railroad boom , had accumulated from Europe and the United States , tens of millions of dollars of notes that were themselves precious assets . The street was barely stirring , but each trip of several hundred yards was escorted by a security guard , armed and alert .
The day before , a small innocuous headline had explained why those clerks were transferring millions of dollars from one office to another : big banking houses decide on merger . Though meriting a front-page mention in The New York Times , the announcement was dwarfed by the two major stories of that day in 1930 : the collapse of the mammoth Bank of United States and the demand by President Herbert Hoover that Congress pass an emergency employment bill to stem the bleeding in the US labor market . In the weeks and months ahead , stories of collapse and chaos would proliferate , but the new banking house survived and thrived . That was surprising , though it shouldn ’ t have been . Brown Brothers had always survived , through crisis after crisis , as it still does today .
What we now call the Great Depression was in full force on December 12 , 1930 , the day of the announcement . More than 1,200 banks had already closed their doors , their deposits lost forever as vaults were drained by panicked customers who had watched the stock market collapse at the end of 1929 and who had then seen a brief false dawn followed by much worse . No
The four sons of Alexander Brown , who founded the firm with their father in Baltimore . federal deposit insurance covered those losses , and no safety net existed to cushion the fall . The panic infected every segment of society , from farming to banking , from manufacturing to retail , and then spread throughout the world .
Yet no outward sign of distress would have been noticed one fall day in 1930 when a group of nattily dressed young men chartered a railcar on the New Haven line to take them from Grand Central Station to their college reunion at Yale . They were a self-confident lot , in their mid-30s , ambitious , all of them born to wealth , none of them having known a day of want . Among them was a tall and lanky man named Prescott Bush . He had married well , wedding the daughter of George Herbert Walker of St . Louis , who had started his own investment firm before becoming president of W . A . Harriman & Co ., founded by Averell Harriman , the debonair yet tight-lipped eldest son of the pugnacious railroad baron E . H . Harriman . Prescott had gone from selling rubber flooring to working as a vice president at Harriman with his college friend Roland “ Bunny ” Harriman , Averell ’ s younger and more easygoing brother .
Roland wasn ’ t on the train that day , but Ellery James and Knight Woolley were . Ellery was a partner at Brown Brothers , and Knight , who was rarely without a bespoke double-breasted suit , was managing partner of another one of the Harriman firms . These young men were entwined by professional and personal bonds , each having been sworn into Yale ’ s exclusive Skull and Bones society before enlisting in the military for America ’ s brief and bloody participation in World War I . Their tight circle included not only the Harriman brothers but also the wiry , intense Robert A . Lovett , whose father , Robert S . Lovett , had served as the elder Harriman ’ s general counsel .
But while they had reveled in the prosperity of the 1920s , they were not immune to the storms outside in 1930 . As they headed to their reunion , cosseted in their private car , playing poker for stakes well in excess of the average weekly wage for millions of Americans , they knew that all was not well in the world . Both Harriman and Brown Brothers were teetering under the weight of credit they had extended to businesses that could no longer repay . Given the deep personal connections between the partners of the firms , it must have seemed organic when the idea of a merger was broached over poker and scotch . Other firms weren ’ t merging ; they were collapsing , and both Harriman and Brown Brothers needed to shore up their business and preserve their capital .
Brown Brothers had more than a century on Harriman ’ s firm . It was a titan of Wall Street , but in reputation and standing rather than size . It was not particularly large in assets , but its influence and reach were as extensive as the flashier J . P . Morgan & Co . or the much larger Chase National Bank , which was infused with Rockefeller money . Because Brown Brothers was a partnership without one figurehead , it attracted neither notoriety nor much public attention , and it did not have the benefit of one man ’ s fortune ever at the ready . The partners of Brown Brothers shunned the public spotlight and cultivated a sterling reputation within the close-knit world of finance and banking . To become a partner , each man had to be invited and then was required to contribute his share to the firm ’ s working capital . Like all partnerships , Brown Brothers lent and invested the partners ’ money . Each deal had to be assessed in terms of how much of their own personal fortune they were willing to risk . In sharp contrast to the investment banks and venture firms and private equity groups of today , the partners at Brown Brothers were not agents acting on behalf of anonymous shareholders or mammoth institutions . Every Brown Brothers partner was personally exposed . They could gain immensely or lose painfully from each deal .
But by the end of 1930 , as the economic collapse accelerated not just in the United States but around the world , transactions and deals that had looked sound and wise a year earlier turned sour . Even after each of the Brown Brothers partners had ponied up more money to cover losses , they were skirting peril . The firm had been in business for more than 120 years , since Alexander Brown set up shop , aided by his four sons , in Baltimore . It was unclear whether it could last into 1931 . Thatcher Brown , great-grandson of Alexander and managing partner of his firm , saw that
www . MoAF . org | Summer 2021 | FINANCIAL HISTORY 15