Pittman Act compelled the US government to purchase American silver at $ 1 an ounce .

According to Israel , in 1921 many members of Congress asked why “ the United States was buying several million ounces of silver — the product of America ’ s mines every month — at 35 cents an ounce above the world market price .” The simple yet frustrating answer was that such purchases were made law via the Pittman Act .

Actual cash losses on silver purchases under the Act were about $ 70 million . The sales to England — which saved British India from turmoil and helped the Allied war effort — totaled around $ 259 million . The repurchase of American silver at $ 1 an ounce replaced that substantial amount . Israel wrote , “ The metallic value of the dollars at the time of sale was approximately $ 200 million . Their metallic value after repurchase was approximately $ 60 million . The differences represented an additional loss .”

There should have been another way to help England in its struggle to acquire the silver needed to save British India . In a dire situation during a world war , the

silver interests — with the help of their lackeys in Congress — forced the American taxpayer to gift them a boondoggle of absurd proportions . In a 1932 article in The North American Review , Neil Carothers wrote , “ That the Congress of the United States should pass such a measure as the Pittman Act is a tragic commentary on government in a democracy .”

Eric Brothers has been a frequent contributor to The Numismatist , the publication of the American Numismatic Association ( ANA ), since 2006 . Several of his articles have covered financial history , including “ Alexander Hamilton and the Panic of 1792 ” ( January 2021 ). He also writes for ANS Magazine , a publication of the American Numismatic Society in New York . This is his fourth article for Financial History .

Sources 65th Congress . “ An Act to Conserve the Gold Supply of the United States …” [“ The Pittman Act ”]. Sess . II . Chap . 63 . 1918 .

Bliss , Don Carroll . “ Sources of Silver Imports : Sea-Borne Trade .” The Bombay Bullion Market . US Government Printing Office , pp . 56 – 57 . 1927 .

Carothers , Neil . “ Silver : A Senate Racket .” The North American Review . Vol . 233 , No . 1 , pp . 4 – 15 . January 1932 .

Israel , Fred L . “ The Fulfillment of Bryan ’ s Dream : Key Pittman and Silver Politics , 1918 – 1933 .” Pacific Historical Review . Vol . 30 , No . 4 , pp . 359 – 380 . November 1961 .

“ Our Silver Saved India From Crisis : Release of $ 200,000,000 at the Urging of Lord Reading Averted Financial Disaster .” The New York Times . August 23 , 1918 .

“ The Silver Situation in the Far East .” The Economic World . New York : Chronicle Company . Vol . 105 , pp . 547 – 549 . April 17 , 1920 .

Typescript of letter from [ Secretary of the Treasury ] W . G . McAdoo to [ Senator ] Key Pittman . March 30 , 1918 .

Unpublished War History . ( Vol . 2 ) Chapter V . “ Gold and Silver .” The Bank of England , 1914 – 1921 . Bank of England Archive ( M7 / 157 ).

THE JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL BOND & SHARE SOCIETY

ENCOURAGING COLLECTING SINCE 1978 NO . 120 - DECEMBER 2022

Winpennys of Manayunk – page 14

National Show to Return Brazilian Diamonds

Auction Explosion !

PUTTING FINANCIAL HISTORY IN YOUR HANDS

Join the International Bond & Share Society , supporting collectors of vintage bonds and shares from all countries for over forty years . For $ 35 , £ 28 or € 32 annually , receive :

Modernizing Certificates

Worldwide Auctions

– page 20

– page 28

5-Figure Frolic – Including : Standard Oil Founder ’ s Share , Antwerp Bond , Nikola Tesla , Embden , Free Society of Traders in Pennsilvania

Deutsche Bank Part 3 – page 16

Charley ’ s Angel – page 23

Three issues a year of our full color 52 page journal Scripophily with news , indepth articles , auction reports and more

Membership Directory listing dealers , auction houses and fellow collectors

Members-only part of the Society website , scripophily . org

Members ’ Newsletters with up-to-date information and event schedule

Subscribe to our Newsletter : www . scripophily . org membership @ scripophily . org

38 FINANCIAL HISTORY | Spring 2023 | www . MoAF . org